Monday, November 22, 2010

Lose the Statistics: Take 2



Last week, I wrote this post about the importance of NOT including statistics in your year-end appeals (and for that matter your year-round appeals) if your goal is to raise more money.

The main point I made is this.  According to research in behavioral economics, statistics actually depress giving by making us go into an analytical vs. empathic state of mind. 

However, I left out an important part of the research.  Please see below.
"A study by researchers Deborah Small, George Lowenstein and Paul Slovic examined the impact difference types of appeals had on charitable giving to a hunger relief organization. 
The first appeal asked donors to help Rokia, a young girl from Mali who was very poor and who faced starvation. 
The second appeal presented facts and statistics about the millions of hungry children facing starvation in African countries. 
The third appeal included BOTH (my emphasis) the personal story and the facts about widespread starvation.

People shown the personal story donated twice as much money overall as those given the facts and figures. 
The third appeal - the combination of the personal story and statistics - worked only slightly better than the facts-only appeal."
Again, we know that statistics alone are BAD, BAD, BAD for fundraising.  Phrases like - "925 million people are going hungry" DO NOT MOVE PEOPLE TO ACTION. 

But what we also know is that EVEN INCLUDING STATISTICS IN A PERSONAL STORY CAN DEPRESS GIVING. 

LOSE THE STATISTICS!  Focus on one story about one individual.  See what happens.


Cheers!

Jocelyn

P.S.  For more on behavioral economics and what it means for your fundraising program, check out this FREE e-book, Homer Simpson for Nonprofits: The Truth About What People Really Think and What it Means for Promoting Your Cause by my friends Katya Andresen of Network for Good, and Alia McKee and Mark Rovner of Sea Change Strategies.

9 comments:

Lance Leasure said...

Great topic! Very profound and thought-provoking.

After reading your post today I was thumbing through the Nov/Dec issue of Advancing Philanthropy and read (Research, Pg. 7) that according to the Cygnus Donor Survey, "73% of survey respondents are more likely to favor giving to nonprofits that provide them with measurable results on what has been or is being achieved with donors' contributions."

Do you suppose that this is referring more to donors who don't receive statistical evidence as an element of on-going donor engagement, and not as part of an appeal?

I would love to learn your thoughts on this.

Keep up the great work!

Jocelyn said...

Hi Lance,

Thanks for your comment!

Can you forward a copy of the Cygnus Donor Survey to me at jocelyn_harmon (at) yahoo (dot) com?

I think that donors do want to know where their dollars are going but I think there is a way to tell that story without invoking dull, boring, statistics.

Jocelyn

lin liyi said...

The most beneficial chanel replica due to this is usually to buy your most liked fake chanel carriers sales on the net. Checking a variety of stores in addition to merchants to buy your completely new clothing collection is usually enjoyment, although from time to time most of us are unable to take away any time to accomplish this.
In addition to when you'd like chanel replica sale seeing that desired to be a Chanel designer purse, most of us are unable to purely get away from the item until finally you could have any time.
The best way to this matter is usually to buy your most liked carriers on the net. There are various internet websites in addition to internet retailers of which stock options the modern year number of hermes replica purses and handbags and it's quite easy to search looking through your do the job workspace to help most of these outlets. Typically plenty of, you can obtain this carriers for a low pace or maybe for a price cut.
Available on the market helps make paying for chanel replica on the net a really superb option.

jordan女鞋 jordan鞋 said...

jordan 鞋介紹
jordan鞋子
jordan 所有鞋款
air jordan鞋款

Lakshya Dhillon said...

happy new year 2017 images

Happy New Year 2017 Message

Leaked Papers

Happy Diwali 2016 Wishes

Black Friday Deals 2016

happy new year 2017 wishes

Valentines Day 2017 Ideas and SMS

Raisa Wilcox said...

New Year 2017 Wallpaper
Happy New Year 2017
Happy New Year 2017
Happy new year
Happy New Year 2017
Happy New Year Images
New Year 2017
New years eve song
Happy New Year 2017 Messages
Merry Christmas Quotes
Happy New Year pictures 2017
merry Christmas and happy new year
Happy New year background 2017
New year wallpaper 2017
New year wallpaper 2017
New Year 2017 Wallpaper
new year background images


Happy New Year 2017
new year celebration 2017
HAPPY NEW YEAR 2017 WALLPAPER
New year 2017 HAPPINESS
HAPPY NEW YEAR 2017
New year 2017 wishes
New year 2017 Messages
New Year Motivation 2017
New Year Motivation 2017
Happy new year and Marry Christmas
New year 2017 wallpaper

chenlina said...

christian louboutin outlet
coach factory outlet
christian louboutin pas cher
christian louboutin paris
ray ban sunglasses
nike air max
mont blanc pens
coach outlet online
nike outlet store
coach outlet
chenlina20161007

hoxn Ln said...

Corvin Lask, left,Replica handbags and Chris Noerskau, co-founders of Slow Replica watches UK . The two set up the company partly as a way to take control of their own time after busy corporate careers.A Rolex Daytona That Tries to Slow Things DownFEB. 23, 2015 .Harry Winston’s Emerald Signature secret handbagreplica layers diamonds of various cuts.Blurring the Lines Between Jewelry and Replica Watches FEB. 23, 2015.Yet at a time when sagging demand in China.

xumeiqing said...

20161111meiqing
louis vuitton bags
ysl outlet online
michael kors outlet
ugg boots
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors canada
coach outlet store
birkenstocks
louis vuitton outlet
uggs canada